Sunday, September 23, 2012

Twitter Race: Which Candidate (or Bashing) Will Win?


Sandhya Kambhampati
sjkambhampati@gmail.com
@sandhya__k


With the release of  Mitt Romney’s hidden camera video,  reporters and news outlets took to Twitter for their newscasts and coverage of the leak.

Here’s the video in case you missed it:


Source: Mother Jones 

Here are some tweets from that day:
Source: Twitter 
It's interesting to note that outlets such as Nightline use the words "political firestorm" to catch tweeters' attention, whereas reporters such as @BuzzFeedAndrew are focused on quoting the video, prompting people to speak up.

While the video bashing began to explode on Twitter, @washingtonpost  tweeted that President Obama was ahead of Romney in the swing states.

Now, it's not just a political race, but a competition for the news outlets to see who gets the news first and who can properly provide the public with access to both candidates.

During this time, there were very few tweets about President Obama.

It almost seemed as if this video made Romney the face of politics on Twitter this week.

Here are some more tweets from later on in the week: 


Source: Twitter 

While it may be important to focus on Romney and his hidden camera video, I think President Obama also needed to be given some attention.  

For one thing, he's still in office and what he's doing right now is extremely important to the election.

While Romney should feel embarrassed of what he said, constant referrals to Romney on Twitter drove his social media appearance up. 

This prompted people to disagree with his video and some to agree, making Romney's slip-up a main focus and an interesting factor to come into play before the debates. 

This brings out the super loyal Republicans and Democrats.

And so, the Twitter battle begins. 
Source: @samsteinhp


It's also interesting that Sunday, September 23rd,  both candidates appeared on 60 Minutes--head to head in competition.

Here's a look at some of the live tweets that were happening during the show.



What do you think of this Twitter coverage this #election2012 ? Tweet @sandhya__k 


Foreign Outlets Pay Attention, Too

Matt Digby
md313208@ohio.edu
@MDigbyOU

Mitt Romney released his tax returns for 2010 & 2011 last week. Photo courtesy Getty Images.
Last week, Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney released his tax returns from the last two years.

I would define this story as the first bit of actual "news" to occur since the end of the conventions. Al Jazeera thought so too, so it posted an article of their own on the release. It is not on the front page, and I had to go well into the "Americas" portion of the site, but it also posted a video about the release, which you can view here:

I don't think this is the fault of Al Jazeera, or any other news organization, but the fact is there haven't been many "juicy" stories since either convention. I have not seen any television ads that sparked outcries from either party, and I doubt AJ broadcasts the ads to their viewers, because most (not all) of them are not American citizens. (Don't forget the active military, who will be receiving their absentee ballots this week!)

Maybe most Americans (and others) don't care about what goes on in the political process in September. With the college football and NFL seasons in full swing, and the MLB playoffs not far away, campaigns and their media coverage are in a harsh competition for a viewer's attention, and the viewer might find sports more entertaining.

Al Jazeera's graphic for their in-depth election coverage.
I am glad to see Al Jazeera is covering something related to the campaign in September, and with the first debate on October 3, I expect to see multiple stories by the next time I post here.

How much do you think "time of year" plays a factor into how much attention people pay to the campaign? Let me know what you think!

FOX: Running out of Headlines

Devin Bartolotta
DevinBart@gmail.com
@HighDEVinition

Despite the fact that nearly every news outlet across the country finds something to analyze, decontextualize, or criticize about the election or specific candidates every single day, FOX news seems to have largely put the presidential race on the back burner when it comes to updated coverage.


I've noticed that, this week in particular, FOX news seems to be running out of things to talk about. The current headline on the FOX news election page is covering Colorado as a swing state.

I could almost hear them in the newsroom, "Hey, did anything significant happen this week? Anyone win yet? No? How about another piece on swing states! That'll get 'em!"

I found myself reading the article and thinking to myself, big deal.

Something new that FOX is incorporating is a Candidate Tracker that highlights stops that Team Romney and Team Obama make throughout the country (And yes, Athens, Ohio has a blue dot for Team Obama's stop a few weeks ago). I don't really know how this feature would pull one's vote in one direction or the other, but it's an interesting feature. I think it shows just how close the media follows these candidates - almost to the point of stalking them.


But as I continued to poke through the site's updates from the weekend, any of the other stories on the site seem to be just about people who don't know what to expect from the election. After headlines like, "Bill Clinton: No 'earthly' idea what Hillary will do next" and  "2012 Challenge: Corral undecided likely voters," I realized how tired I am of news outlets stating the obvious: presidential elections are very predictably unpredictable. Many of these headlines could have been carbon copied from articles in 2008, with a mere substitution of names.

One article that I found extremely interesting was about Romney's health. Looking back, the health and age of John McCain were in the headlines constantly in 2008. It details his height, weight, and all the medical problems he does (and some that he doesn't) have. This might be a way for Romney to separate himself from the previous republican candidate, or maybe just his way of reassuring America that taking baby aspirin really does wonderful things for your cholesterol.

But for FOX news, I imagine that analyzing how Obamacare would view that method of treatment would be a whole other story.

NBC Nightly News & The Importance of Fact Checking

Carolyn Menyes
c.menyes@gmail.com
@athousandmph

There is just no denying it... The biggest story in the presidential race last week was the video of a leaked Mitt Romney speech from a private fundraiser.



The clip, originally posted by Mother Jones, sent shockwaves through the political sphere and voters. Here, democrats saw an opportunity to attack Romney, while republicans had to defend and clarify the remarks.

Brian Williams and the NBC Nightly News team took a different approach than many outlets. They decided to fact check the now infamous "47 percent" remarks in an extremely well done and accurate two minute segment.


Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

This fact checking showed that the "47 percent" does, in fact, exist: but they don't necessarily look like what Republicans or Romney would expect. This segment of the population consists of students, veterans, seniors and those who don't make enough money to pay an income tax (though they would pay a payroll tax). As Williams points out, many of the people Romney blasted are his very own supporters: older white males with high school diplomas.

This segment, entitled "Reality Check," is a semi-regular bit on NBC Nightly News. This shows a growing trend in journalism for politics, known as the fact check. In an age where politicians speak hyperbolically and as Stephen Colbert would say "from the gut," facts get misinterpreted, twisted and thrown out the window, it's not enough to just report on the news. Journalists have to make sure sound clips are valid.

As discussed in class, journalists are no longer the filter. Politicians, active social media users and bloggers often decide what is, in fact, news. So, while this may seem troubling for our profession, it just means we have to change our role. Now, it is incredibly important for journalists to keep a close eye on politicians.

When someone says 47 percent of people don't pay taxes and are therefore unnecessary to worry about: that's a problem. But it may be true (at least in part). The American people need to know what is and is not a factual statement. So then, it must be the journalists job to tell them.

I commend NBC Nightly News for this "Reality Check" segment, which was done in an unbiased manner. He clarified the remarks that Romney did not eloquently state himself. This segment was more than just gossip: it was fact. And that is what we need.

Easy on Mitt: NPR Doesn't Overstate Romney's Mistakes

Seaira Christian-Daniels
@seairacdaniels
seaira.daniels@gmail.com

NPR news isn't totally condemning Mitt Romney, even if other news organizations are.

In fact, on NPR.org 's main page,  only one of the top five stories specifically--though fleetingly--mentions the upcoming elections in light of the 75th anniversary of the New Deal.
In NPR's political section, news stories ranged in headlines from highlighting the increase in number of women running for congresswomen to quirky restaurant polls using cocktails and cheeses as a gauge for Democratic or Republican success. 

The two stories pertaining to Obama and Romney pitted the Democratic and Republican strategies against one another, stating that Americans will have to wait until debate night to see which candidate will be the "best seller" of their policies to the American people.

Small Section with Large Number of Insights

It is only when one navigates to the elections column that Romney's big gaffes are explained in detail.

However, I was impressed with the amount of details NPR included about Mitt Romney's resurfacing tax tensions.

Included with the report was the front page of Romney's tax return, Democrat and GOP commentary on the Romney tax release, and a side-by-side comparison of the past 2 years of Obama and Romney taxes to the past 2 years of Biden and Ryan's.

Otherwise, the stories covered were largely issue based, focusing on voter suppression, and two stories focusing on the senate races, which had not been largely covered in previous weeks.

Perhaps this is exactly what Romney's camp hoped for, according to NPR's Frank James: that by the time the first presidential debate airs, this whole situation will be "old news."

CNN, "Forty-Seven-Gate," and Tax Returns -- Oh My!


Keara Vickers
keara.vickers@gmail.com

Romney may have been talking about 47% of Americans, but it seems like 100% of CNN’s political coverage is about the blowback from his gaff-filled campaign.
The talk of the political town has been about the Mother Jones article linking to a video taken from a private fundraising dinner in which Romney admonished the non-tax paying group and said "[his] job is not to worry about those people. [He’ll] never convince them they should take personal responsibility and care for their lives." Ouch.

CNN took the latest Romney blunder and ran with it, ruthlessly following the aftermath but doing little in the way of real investigation. Perhaps it's out of an effort to remain visibly nonpartisan but CNN has failed in being the people's watchdog and has acted more as a commentator -- like a political John Madden without the amusing metaphors.

From CNN Election 2012: Romney finally gets front-page
attention, but for all the wrong reasons.
And speaking of taxes, Romney finally released his 2011 tax returns after months of criticism and speculation. CNN has done a fair job of untangling the meaning behind the paperwork -- and hasn’t let Romney get away from what might be lurking taxless in his offshore accounts. 

On CNN’s Sunday State of the Union, Republican senator Lindsey Grahm came to Romney’s defense in a tense interview available to view here. While Senator Grahm highlighted how Romney’s economic plan gives him the edge, President Obama’s campaign isn’t about to let “forty-seven-gate” get swept under the rug. Fresh off of his huge DNC speech, former president Clinton came out swinging against Romney’s comments and hinted that the Republican missteps could swing the country into an electoral landslide toward a second Democratic presidency.

So, could this have been the early October Surprise that will put the final nail in the election 2012 coffin? Romney goes head-to-head with President Obama on October 3rd in round one of televised debates that could truly make or break this election.

The BBC making Romney's bed. Or is he?

Bradley W. Parks
bp124509@ohio.edu
@Bradley_W_Parks

Finally, after a week of waiting, the BBC returned to the ballgame of covering the United States presidential election. And after allowing a week's worth of events play out for observation, it appears the BBC's coverage is putting Governor Mitt Romney to bed in this election.

It seems terribly early to jump to conclusions, but after a campaign of missteps for Mr. Romney, his coverage is going south, not just on the BBC, but other media outlets as well.

The BBC took the time to highlight Mr. Romney's "private" fundraiser PR gaffes, explain the magnitude of the mistakes and analyze their effects on the election.

Meanwhile, President Barack Obama flew under the radar this past week. Taking a look at the BBC's US election page, seven of eleven front page stories and videos focus on Mr. Romney.

Eight of the front page stories at the very least make note of Mr. Romney's remarks in the secret video provided by liberal news magazine Mother Jones. All four videos on the front page deal directly with the remarks, while four of the written stories make mention.

So while Mr. Romney receives such negative coverage from the BBC, his deficit in the "Poll of Polls" is growing.

After the Republican National Convention, Mr. Romney enjoyed a slight one percent lead. However, in the time since, the gap has jumped an entire four percentage points in favor of Mr. Obama to give the incumbent a three percent lead.

The BBC's coverage made Mr. Romney's woes a primary feature on its website. The governor's fall has the BBC seemingly putting him to bed as the loser of this election before ballots have even been cast.

However, after seeing the events play out this past week, the fall may be Mr. Romney's own doing.